In this post, I share fifteen classroom activities built around thinking routines from Project Zero at the Harvard Graduate School of Education. The activities help students record observations, explain interpretations, connect ideas, consider perspectives, and revisit their understanding. Each includes a classroom example and something students can produce or discuss.
For teachers interested in integrating critical thinking into their teaching, my book Critical Thinking with AI includes 81 activities. It offers further opportunities to practise examining evidence, explaining judgments, and reflecting on decisions.
Project Zero developed the routines introduced here across its research projects. The descriptions below are paraphrased, and the classroom examples are suggested applications. Links lead to the original instructions and downloadable resources. Project Zero’s Thinking Routines Toolbox
Choosing a Visible Thinking Routine
| Your lesson goal | Routines to consider |
|---|---|
| Observe closely and develop questions | See, Think, Wonder; Think, Puzzle, Explore |
| Explain an interpretation | What Makes You Say That?; Claim, Support, Question |
| Develop an idea through discussion | Think, Pair, Share; Chalk Talk |
| Consider perspectives | Circle of Viewpoints; Step Inside |
| Examine a proposal | Compass Points |
| Organize and synthesize learning | Headlines; Color, Symbol, Image; Generate-Sort-Connect-Elaborate; The 4 Cs |
| Track developing understanding | Connect, Extend, Challenge; I Used to Think… Now I Think… |
1. See, Think, Wonder
Focus — Distinguishing observations from interpretations and developing questions.
Show students a photograph, object, or diagram. Give them time to describe visible details before explaining what those details suggest. Then collect questions that could guide further investigation.
Classroom activity. Use a photograph of a crowded railway platform. Students list visible details, propose an interpretation, and identify what they would need to know about the place and date to check it.
Collect — A three-column response with observations, interpretations, and questions. Return to one question after introducing a related source.
2. What Makes You Say That?
Focus — Explaining the basis for an interpretation.
When students offer an explanation, invite them to identify what led them to it. Give them time to point to a passage, observation, or relevant prior knowledge.
Classroom activity. Read a scene in which a character repeatedly checks the door during a conversation. Students offer an interpretation, then identify the details behind it. Compare whether those same details permit another reading.
Collect — A claim paired with the detail that prompted it and an explanation of the connection.
3. Claim, Support, Question
Focus — Developing a supported position and identifying what remains unresolved.
Students propose a claim about a topic, identify support, and raise a question about the claim or its basis.
Classroom activity. Give students a small practice dataset showing playground temperatures in shaded and unshaded locations. Ask for a claim that fits the measurements, supporting values, and a question about what other observations would help.
Collect — A claim, relevant measurements, and a question that could lead to another investigation.
4. Think, Pair, Share
Focus — Preparing an idea and developing it through conversation.
Give students a question and individual thinking time. Partners exchange explanations before the class discusses selected responses.
Classroom activity. Present two ways to solve a fraction problem. Students choose a method, explain their choice to a partner, and identify a feature of the other approach they found useful.
Collect — A brief individual response after the conversation explaining what became clearer.
Find the original routine in the toolbox
5. Think, Puzzle, Explore
Focus — Identifying initial ideas and planning inquiry.
Students record their current thinking, identify questions that puzzle them, and suggest ways to investigate.
Classroom activity. Before a unit on drinking water, students explain where they think tap water comes from. They identify a question and choose a possible source, such as a municipal diagram or a local expert.
Collect — One inquiry question paired with a realistic next step.
6. Connect, Extend, Challenge
Focus — Linking new information to prior knowledge and identifying emerging difficulties.
After reading or viewing, students explain a connection to what they knew, an idea that broadened their thinking, and a question or difficulty that remains.
Classroom activity. Read about an unfamiliar pollinator. Students connect the reading to a familiar plant, explain one new ecological relationship, and identify something they still need to investigate.
Collect — Three short notes with references to the reading where relevant.
7. I Used to Think… Now I Think…
Focus — Explaining how understanding develops.
Return students to an earlier idea and ask what they would say now. Encourage them to explain the evidence or experience behind a change or clarification.
Classroom activity. After comparing two accounts of a historical decision, students revisit their initial explanation of why it happened. They identify a detail that complicated or strengthened their view.
Collect — An earlier statement, a current statement, and the reason for the difference. Students whose views stayed consistent can explain what became clearer.
8. Circle of Viewpoints
Focus — Recognizing that people can approach the same issue with different concerns.
Identify perspectives connected to an issue. Students explore what a particular person might notice or ask, using available evidence.
Classroom activity. Examine a proposal to change bus routes using statements from riders, drivers, and planners. Students identify each perspective’s concerns and formulate a question that person might raise.
Collect — A perspective, a supporting source detail, and a question. Label guesses and seek direct accounts before attributing views to a community.
9. Step Inside
Focus — Exploring what a character or figure might perceive, understand, and care about.
Use details from a text or image to consider a perspective, then discuss where the evidence runs out.
Classroom activity. Read a fictional scene in which a new student arrives during a group task. Students consider what the character could see, what they might understand, and what could matter to them.
Collect — A short interpretation with one textual detail and one uncertainty.
10. Compass Points
Focus — Examining a proposal before deciding how to proceed.
Organize responses around what seems promising, what causes concern, what students need to know, and their current stance or suggestions.
Classroom activity. Propose replacing part of a school lawn with a garden. Students examine possible benefits, maintenance concerns, missing information, and changes they would suggest.
Collect — A provisional recommendation that identifies what must be checked next.
11. Headlines
Focus — Identifying and communicating a central idea.
Ask students to create a short headline that captures what they consider most important in a lesson, reading, or discussion. Have them explain their choice.
Classroom activity. After investigating erosion, students write a headline describing the relationship between moving water and soil. Partners check whether the wording fits the observations.
Collect — A headline and one sentence explaining the idea it foregrounds.
12. Color, Symbol, Image
Focus — Representing ideas through visual choices and explaining their meaning.
Students choose a colour, a symbol, and an image associated with important ideas in the material. The explanations show how they interpreted it.
Classroom activity. After a story about belonging, students make their visual choices and connect each to a detail. Invite different interpretations of the same colour or symbol.
Collect — Three visual representations with short written or recorded explanations. Assess the connections students explain.
13. Chalk Talk
Focus — Developing a written conversation that students can revisit.
Display a substantial question. Students respond in writing, read classmates’ contributions, and add questions or connections. End with a discussion of patterns and unresolved ideas.
Classroom activity. Ask what makes a classroom discussion useful. Students add specific examples, connect related comments, and identify a question about how to put the ideas into practice.
Collect — A summary of one pattern and a proposed next step. Use a shared document or pass a paper around a seated group when that better supports participation.
14. Generate-Sort-Connect-Elaborate
Focus — Organizing ideas and explaining relationships.
Students generate relevant ideas, arrange them, connect them, and add details that develop the emerging map.
Classroom activity. Give students the focus question “How does water move through this landscape?” They generate concepts from a unit, organize them, and connect ideas with explanations such as “flows into” or “is absorbed by.”
Collect — A concept map and an explanation of one connection students added during revision.
15. The 4 Cs
Focus — Discussing connections, challenges, important concepts, and implications for change.
Use a substantial reading that students have time to examine. Ask them to relate it to other knowledge, identify ideas they want to question, select central concepts, and consider implications.
Classroom activity. Read an argument about protecting a local habitat. Students connect it to a previous lesson, question one assumption, identify a central concept, and suggest a change in practice the argument could support.
Collect — Four brief notes and a source-based explanation of the point they most want to discuss.
Use the Same Routine Again
Choose a routine that fits a recurring lesson goal and use it with several different materials. Model a response, give students individual thinking time, and decide how to record their ideas. Offer written, spoken, or visual responses where appropriate.
Save the first responses and revisit them after another reading, discussion, or investigation. Ask students which idea they would revise and what prompted the revision. Project Zero recommends using routines repeatedly and returning to documented thinking as understanding develops. Project Zero’s guidance







