In this post, I compare five ways to generate critical-thinking questions for classroom discussions, reading assignments, and short assessments. I also share a copy-ready prompt and examples of how to revise questions so students have to interpret evidence, weigh alternatives, or explain a judgment.
I’d start by naming what students need to do with the content. If the goal is to evaluate evidence, give them something to evaluate and a decision to make. A question can begin with analyze and still ask students to repeat a conclusion they already read.
Critical-Thinking Question Generators at a Glance
| Option | Best for | What to give it | What to review |
|---|---|---|---|
| MagicSchool | Drafting questions at different levels of cognitive demand | The topic, lesson goal, and relevant content | Whether students actually need to reason at the level indicated |
| Brisk Teaching | Writing questions around an article, video, or PDF | The resource students will use | Whether the questions refer to details students can locate in the resource |
| Diffit | Pairing accessible readings with open-ended questions | A topic or source and the intended reading level | Whether different versions give students access to the evidence they need |
| Wayground | Drafting and delivering short digital assessments | The topic, source material, or questions you want to adapt | Whether the format lets students show why they chose an answer |
| General-purpose AI chatbot | Creating questions tied to a particular thinking skill | The source, grade level, skill, and expected response | Whether it invented details or left out a plausible interpretation |
1. MagicSchool for Questions With Different Thinking Demands
MagicSchool offers a Depth of Knowledge (DOK) question generator. I’d use its output to build a sequence for a single lesson. Start with a question that helps students locate information, then add one that makes them use that information to reach a conclusion.
For example, after students locate two measurements in a science table, ask which explanation those measurements support and which new measurement would help them decide between two explanations. Read the generated questions before using the DOK labels. Ask yourself what students would actually have to do to answer each one. See MagicSchool’s DOK generator overview
2. Brisk Teaching for Questions About an Existing Resource
Brisk’s DOK question generator can work from an article, video, or PDF. It’s a useful starting point when you already have a reading and want students to spend more time on a particular passage. For a historical account, ask for a question about one claim the author makes and one detail students could use to assess it.
Open the source next to the generated question. Check any quoted words and locate the evidence students would need. If the question asks about information outside the source, decide whether finding that information is part of your lesson. See Brisk’s DOK question generator
3. Diffit for Accessible Readings With a Shared Thinking Goal
Diffit offers adapted reading resources and open-ended claim–evidence–reasoning activities. If students are reading different versions of a passage, keep a common question where possible. For instance, ask everyone to decide which proposed solution has stronger support. Check that each version preserves the details students need to make that decision. See Diffit’s instructional resources
4. Wayground for Short Digital Checks
Wayground can draft questions and deliver them as a digital assessment. A useful format is a two-part item. First, students choose the conclusion best supported by a small dataset. Then they identify the data point that most influenced their answer and explain why. If you use multiple choice, make each incorrect option represent a distinct misunderstanding so you can see what to revisit. See Wayground’s assessment creation guide
5. An AI Chatbot for Questions You Can Specify in Detail
Use this option when the question needs to fit a particular source or skill. Provide the excerpt, data, or scenario and name the reasoning you want to see. Here’s a prompt you can copy and adapt.
Write four critical-thinking questions for Grade [grade] students studying [topic]. Use the source or data I provide below. The learning goal is [goal]. Include one question that asks students to interpret a detail, one that asks them to compare two plausible explanations, one that asks them to evaluate the strength of the evidence, and one that asks them to apply an idea to a new situation. For each question, state what a strong response would include and identify any other defensible answer. If the source lacks enough information for a question, say what evidence is missing. Keep the wording accessible to [grade or reading level].
Source or dataset: [paste here]
How to Improve a Generated Question
The examples below use short teacher-prepared materials. Pair each prompt with the source, text, or data students need to examine.
| Subject | First draft | Revised question |
|---|---|---|
| Science | What happened to the seedlings? | One group grew taller but had paler leaves. What does each observation suggest? What else would you measure before deciding which growing condition was better? |
| Social studies | What reasons did the council give for closing the market? | The council memo emphasizes repair costs, while a shopkeeper’s letter emphasizes access to affordable food. What would you need to know to decide how the closure might affect residents? |
| ELA | How does Maya feel before her performance? | Maya says she is ready, grips her notes, and asks twice when she will go on. Which detail carries the most weight in your interpretation of how she feels? Explain why. |
| AI literacy | Is the chatbot’s answer accurate? | The chatbot says a phone rule raised grades. The school report records fewer interruptions but includes no grade data. What can you conclude from the report, and what question remains open? |
Before assigning the questions, answer one yourself with the materials students will have. If your answer simply repeats a sentence from the reading, add a comparison, a competing explanation, or a judgment students have to defend. If you can’t point to evidence for a reasonable answer, revise the question or add a source.








