In this post, I share 100 critical-thinking question stems students can use to clarify ideas, examine evidence, question assumptions, compare perspectives, and explain their judgments. You can adapt them for class discussions, reading responses, research projects, peer feedback, and evaluating AI-generated content.
For those interested in integrating critical thinking into their teaching, my book Critical Thinking with AI includes 81 activities to help you bring this work into the classroom. The question stems below give you language you can introduce in a lesson and return to as students work through a text, a problem, or a decision.
Choose a Question Stem That Fits the Task
| When students need to… | Start with… |
|---|---|
| Clarify a term | What does _____ mean in this context? |
| Check a claim | Which part of this claim can we verify? |
| Evaluate evidence | How directly does this evidence support _____? |
| Identify an assumption | What has to be true for this explanation to work? |
| Consider another perspective | How might _____ interpret this differently? |
| Explain a judgment | Why did you give more weight to _____? |
| Reflect on their reasoning | Which part of my answer should I reconsider? |
1. Clarify Ideas and Define Terms
Use these stems when students use a broad term, interpret a question differently, or need to make a claim more precise.
- What does _____ mean in this context?
- How would you explain _____ in your own words?
- What example would help someone understand _____?
- What would count as a nonexample of _____?
- Which part of this statement needs a clearer definition?
- How is _____ different from _____?
- What exactly is this question asking us to decide?
- Which words could different readers interpret differently?
- How could we make this claim more precise?
- What distinction do we need to make before continuing?
Try it in class. Before discussing whether a school rule is fair, ask students to define fairness and explain how their definition applies to one part of the rule.
Related: Teaching With AI: A Step by Step Guide for Teachers
2. Examine Claims and Arguments
Use these questions to help students work out what someone is claiming and how the argument is built.
- What is the main claim being made?
- Which reasons does the writer give for this claim?
- How does the conclusion follow from those reasons?
- Which part of the argument is strongest, and why?
- Which step in the argument needs more explanation?
- Does the conclusion go beyond what the evidence supports?
- What qualification would make this claim more defensible?
- Is the same term used consistently throughout the argument?
- What objection would the writer need to address?
- How would you reconstruct this argument in three sentences?
Try it in class. Give students a short opinion paragraph. Have them underline the claim, identify the reasons, and propose one qualification that improves its precision.
3. Evaluate Evidence and Sources
Ask students to have the source in front of them when answering. Their responses should identify a passage, finding, or observation they can show someone else.
- What evidence supports this claim?
- Where did this information originally come from?
- How directly does this evidence support _____?
- What makes this source suitable for this particular question?
- What does this source allow us to conclude?
- What does the source leave unresolved?
- Which details would we need to verify independently?
- Do these two sources provide independent evidence?
- How might the method used to collect the evidence affect the result?
- What additional evidence would strengthen or weaken the claim?
Try it in class. Compare a headline with the study summary it cites. Ask students to identify the outcome the study measured and decide whether the headline describes it accurately.
4. Question Assumptions and Generalizations
These stems help students identify what an explanation takes for granted and examine how broadly it applies.
- What is this explanation taking for granted?
- What has to be true for this conclusion to hold?
- Which assumption could we test?
- How might our own expectations affect our interpretation?
- Who or what is included in this generalization?
- What example would challenge this statement?
- Under what conditions might this claim fail?
- How much variation does this description overlook?
- What are we assuming about the people involved?
- How would the argument change if this assumption were false?
Try it in class. Present the statement “Students learn better when they work in groups.” Ask students to specify the task, group arrangements, and evidence they would need to evaluate it.
5. Compare Perspectives and Representation
Use these questions when reading accounts of the same event, examining a policy, or considering whose experiences appear in a source.
- How might _____ interpret this situation differently?
- Whose perspective is most visible in this account?
- Whose perspective would help us understand the issue more fully?
- What experiences might explain these different interpretations?
- What do these accounts agree on?
- Where do their priorities differ?
- How does the choice of language shape the reader’s impression?
- What would we need to ask the people represented here?
- Which source could help us investigate a missing perspective?
- How can we represent this disagreement accurately?
Try it in class. Compare two accounts of a proposed market closure. Ask students to identify each writer’s priorities and suggest a source that could add another perspective.
6. Make Inferences and Explain Causes
These stems give students a way to connect observations to explanations and consider alternatives.
- What can we reasonably infer from these details?
- Which observation carries the most weight in your interpretation?
- What alternative explanation fits the same evidence?
- What evidence would help us distinguish between these explanations?
- What happened before the change?
- What other factor could have contributed to the outcome?
- What connects the proposed cause to the effect?
- What comparison would help us investigate this explanation?
- How certain can we be, given the available information?
- Which part of our explanation remains tentative?
Try it in class. Give students plant-growth data with height and leaf-colour observations. Ask them to compare two explanations and identify a measurement that would help decide between them.
7. Solve Problems and Weigh Decisions
Use these stems before students recommend a solution. Give them criteria and enough information to compare the options.
- What problem are we trying to solve?
- Who experiences this problem, and how?
- What evidence shows the size or nature of the problem?
- What constraints must a solution meet?
- What options have we considered?
- Which criteria should guide our decision?
- What trade-off does each option involve?
- What unintended consequence should we investigate?
- What small trial could help us compare the options?
- What result would make us reconsider our recommendation?
Try it in class. Have students compare two plans for reducing lunch waste. Ask them to recommend a short trial and name what they would measure before and afterward.
related: Classroom Essentials for Teachers
8. Explain Reasoning and Respond to Others
Post a few of these stems during discussion or peer review so students can build on a particular idea.
- How did you move from _____ to _____?
- Why did you give more weight to this detail?
- Which part of your reasoning would you explain further?
- How does your evidence connect to your conclusion?
- How does your interpretation account for _____?
- Can you clarify what you meant by _____?
- How does your point connect with _____’s observation?
- What part of this disagreement can we resolve using the source?
- How would you respond to the objection that _____?
- What common ground could help us move the discussion forward?
Try it in class. During peer review, ask students to select one claim in a partner’s draft and use a question stem to request a clearer connection between evidence and conclusion.
9. Evaluate AI-Generated Content
Pair these stems with the original source whenever a chatbot summarizes, interprets, or makes claims about it.
- Which claims in this response can we verify?
- Does the cited source exist, and does it support the statement?
- What did the original source actually measure or describe?
- Which qualification from the source is missing here?
- What important perspective or detail should we investigate further?
- How might the wording of our prompt have shaped this answer?
- What would count as independent confirmation of this claim?
- Which part of the response should we accept, revise, or reject, and why?
- How could we rewrite this answer to reflect the available evidence?
- What can I explain about this topic without relying on the AI response?
Try it in class. Use a simulated chatbot answer claiming that a phone rule improved grades. Pair it with a fictional report that recorded interruptions and collected no grade data. Ask students to rewrite the claim within the evidence available.
10. Reflect and Reconsider
Use these questions after students receive feedback, compare interpretations, or revisit an earlier response.
- What did I initially think, and what do I think now?
- Which detail changed or clarified my understanding?
- Where did I feel confident before checking the evidence?
- Which part of my answer should I reconsider?
- What did I do when my first approach stopped working?
- Which strategy helped me make progress?
- What question is still unresolved?
- What feedback did I use, and how did I use it?
- What would I do differently on a similar task?
- What evidence would show that my understanding has improved?
Try it in class. Ask students to choose one answer they revised and explain which evidence or feedback prompted the change.
How to Use the Question Stems in a Lesson
Choose two or three stems that fit the work students are doing. Model one response using the class text or problem, then give students time to try the same move. A sentence starter such as “This detail supports my interpretation because…” can help students develop the explanation their question calls for.
For younger students, shorten the wording to “What makes you think that?”, “Where did you find it?”, or “What else could explain it?” Allow a spoken response or a labelled drawing when that suits the task.
Return to the response at the end of the lesson. Ask students to underline the detail they used, explain how it supports their answer, and identify anything they still need to check. You can then decide which question stem to model again next time.







